Recent content by Li Shenron

  1. Li Shenron

    D&D General NPC help/ question regarding creating characters above 1st level.

    In theory, 5e does not set a default for how much treasure should the PC find, and therefore does not have wealth-by-level tables in PHB or DMG. So if you only had the PHB, the starting equipment packages in the Classes chapter (or starting wealth-by-class table in the Equipment chapter) are...
  2. Li Shenron

    D&D 5E (2014) Is Point Buy Balanced?

    If you want a summarised yes/no response, I personally think it's balanced enough. If you want a detailed analysis, I don't think it's possible to have one that is exhaustive, and what might seem a better scores array in one game, could be worse in another, depending on party composition...
  3. Li Shenron

    D&D General The Monsters Know What They're Doing ... Are Unsure on 5e24

    Keith knows what he's doing. I've said it countless of times, I've spotted the trend already at Tasha's book, and I am happy that I stopped my D&D purchases at that point (meaning, without getting Tasha's).
  4. Li Shenron

    Modules: Made to Read vs Made to Run?

    I don't think published adventures are excessively narrative, but I am certainly forever waiting for someone to figure out such a good module layout that would allow me to read it for the first time when I am running it.
  5. Li Shenron

    Why do we need thieves??

    Many systems are based on character classes or archetypes. The "sneaky trickster" who gets what they want by subterfuge is a favourite archetype so it often gets included. "Thief" is always a debatable name for the archetype, as the person doesn't have to be interested or willing to steal, in...
  6. Li Shenron

    Unearthed Arcana WOTC still can't get the backgrounds right in the new FR book.

    2024 backgrounds have almost nothing to do with "story"
  7. Li Shenron

    Circle Casting Details Revealed for Forgotten Realms: Heroes of Faerun

    I don't understand how it works within combat initiative: "The secondary casters must take the Magic action and be near the caster to contribute to the spell", but when does it happen? Does the spell go off when the last caster takes their action? Does the primary caster need to be the first...
  8. Li Shenron

    D&D General Combat Against Player Engagement: A Systemic Challenge

    Interesting thoughts. Keeping in mind that not all players are the same, therefore there is no solution which works for everyone at the same table, here are also some thoughts of mine. 1) Procedural segmentation has the benefit of making combat simpler in a few ways. First of all, it...
  9. Li Shenron

    D&D 5E (2024) Rank 5e skills from most useful (1) to least useful (18)

    1- any skill one of my PC has 1- any skill one of my PC has 1- any skill one of my PC has 1- any skill one of my PC has ... If they have it, I make sure they will find it useful. But then another question is... after 10 years, how many players still haven't understood that "having a skill" is...
  10. Li Shenron

    D&D 5E (2024) Help me Houserule 5e Equipment & Items

    Some random comments... This shouldn't be too difficult. Go through the list of magic items and for each one try thinking of a non-magical explanation for its effects: biological, materials-based, or technological. It can be a fantasy explanation if you need, without qualifying as fully magic...
  11. Li Shenron

    D&D 5E (2014) Thoughts on bonus action potions?

    Well mostly I do think it just makes the game (even) easier. Potions more or less are like stored spells. They already have the advantage of going beyond the daily slots limits of your party's spellcasters, and obviously being usable directly by the target without even requiring a spellcaster...
  12. Li Shenron

    Which are you, The plan everything out GM, or the Ad lib?

    I am definitely a planner. I start by reading a published adventure carefully, then typically in the days or weeks before the game night I find myself thinking a lot about everything between the established elements of the adventure, kind of filling up the space, adding things of my own, or...
  13. Li Shenron

    Time travel doesn't exist because time travel wiped out the timelines where it did

    I don't think "time" is really what we think it is. I recommend reading "The Order of Time" by physicist Carlo Rovelli to get a new perspective.
  14. Li Shenron

    D&D General Take A Look At The Class Boards From The New D&D Starter Set

    I think the classboards are cool. Unfortunately they are a bit specific to the box pregens. Shouldn't be too difficult to turn them into templates. Even then, there are classes with fairly different needs, so I don't think a one-size-fit-all exists, just like with character sheets. I already...
  15. Li Shenron

    D&D 5E (2024) NPCs, and the poverty of the core books

    When I want to make an important NPC myself, I pretty much always make it using PC rules, i.e. race + class + background in 5e. I may skim on some details like not filling up all its known spells and proficiencies allowance. I may on the other hand also give it some extras if it fits. I...
Top