mamba's latest activity

they both publish one setting only, it would be weird for them to have options that they exclude from that setting

Right, because ToV and A5E are of an equivalent design quality of 5.5. There is nothing special about 5.5 -- or, really, D&D, beyond its...

I agree, but that also means they are no worse, just less popular.

it goes further than that, you get XP rewards for playing the DS races according to their description ("The notes given on roleplaying...

Yeah. TSR essentially designed a stealth new RPG that was both incompatible with AD&D's PHB and yet still required it for the things...

moreso than they do with 5.5?

I think that if either A5E or ToV had come from WotC with the D&D logo on them, essentially everyone would applaud them as a great 5.5.

Yeah. I agree. While I have very strong feelings on how excluding options helps to give a setting its identity (I'm all for it) - the...

Yeah exactly. We don't need the exact same classes/subclasses/species/etc. as 2E or 4E Dark Sun, but having default restrictions to set...

I have ideas what sort of Paladins could exist in Dark Sun despite 2e Dark Sun having a ban on Paladins. In many ways I feel it comes...

yes, for one that was 4e, 15 or so years ago, for another it already says ‘but if a player wants to play a different race, here is how...

I know it's kind of just accepted that DH is doing great...but I'd love to get an actual number on these print runs that are selling out...

not sure it takes a feeling for that, the CR announcement should he enough

Ill assume by no one, you actually mean...you.

Again, imaginary wishes thread.