Mannahnin's latest activity

Obviously we have different experiences and opinions and preferences, here, and I'm not going to try to argue you out of yours (and you...

Do you think we should expect people to respond to losing a 20-minute game of magic in the same way as they'd react to a loss involving...

The typical way over-optimization is a problem is when a given character outshines other characters, and makes the players of those...

How is discrepancy in optimization a problem, outside of jerk behavior? There's the en passant steamrollering of someone else's...

We probably have different opinions on this--which is fine--but my take on 5e is the problems you're talking about are probably more a...

Yeah, for sure. I vaguely remember an old 3e thread (not here) about how a player who just naively wanted to play a shapeshifting and...

I would say "No" except there will always be someone who chooses the wrong tool for the job and then complains how it is a bad tool.

I guess it depends what a person means by running an OSR game using DH. What you describe sounds very similar to how I do things...

Is it possible to do dungeon crawls in PbtA? Yes. See Dungeon World. More specifically, see Perilous Wilds which is probably one of the...

Ok? But I was suggesting since it’s a fiction-first / scene framed game looking at how it handles the genre might be useful for people...

Ok, ran the game for the first time. An incredibly positive experience for me personally and for pretty much everyone at the table (6...

Yes, though considering you also have essentially the opportunity to do the same on any failed roll, any time the PCs give you a "Golden...

I would almost want a Supply/Resource track on the character sheet that you could threaten as the GM using GM moves. This is something...

It helps that Eberron can support a lot of frames. Depending on what you want to spotlight, you can borrow from 5 Banners Burning for a...

This just fiction. I would simply tailor the frame itself to what's there for how much effort I want to put in. You dont actually have...