Mannahnin's latest activity

Not as weapons, but they could still use such a trident as a low charge extra-long wand of fish command or marine predator detection. :)...

Cheaters. For my long term AD&D campaign I allowed anything from official sources from stuff I had (UA and OA at the time and then some...

I remember (and the 2E DMG suggests) simple double damage on 20s being the most common crit rule, though critical hit charts with all...

If they were doing a Kickstarter, I would bet on the module being available for backers as a way to get some extra cash relatively...

Yeah, even Mentzer has acknowledged that was a mistake and apologized publicly for it. It would have been much better to give them new...

Yes there is, it's literally in the book. I gave you the page on my first response, the other issue is Reactions, which is absolutely...

No luck tokens, at 3rd level? We already know the DM was awful. That's just another stone in the sling. At 3rd level if Human you had...

Yes, you played with bad DMs who didn't even know or follow the games rules. We covered that.

The Rules Cyclopedia is 1991 and the Complete Fighters Handbook 1989 anyway. Mentzer vs Moldvay has all sorts of interesting little...

They can miss all their attacks in a given round, get hit by a round of attacks and die. This is less likely to happen to the Wizard...

No. You're conflating and confusing different things from several different editions now. Remember that enemies DON'T get saving...

Then there shouldn't be anymore limits on spells cast per day than melee swings per day. Otherwise there is a huge difference.