Recent content by MatthewJHanson

I think it would be perfectly easy to do. As others have said, there are other games that do the same. There are even some pros, like having a cleric able to actually remember more about religion than the wizard. I think it would be pretty easy to implement too, but just upping proficiency...

Yeah, fantasy RPG weapons require some suspension of disbelief (much like dragons being able to fly). If there isn't an actual historical weapon like that there's probably good reason. Even historical weapons are often quite different from how they appear in art. Battle axes, for example...

I like that the Lady of Pain has a clear brick underneath her so she can float above the ground.

20 Talking Treasures is now available! The powerful ring that wants to return to its master. The chaos blade that forces its wielder into a murderous rage. Magic items with a mind of their own are a staple of fantasy fiction. In fantasy roleplaying games they can add conflict or comic relief...

I think the Stormlight RPG will do very well, though I would not assume that RPG are less of a niche than fancy editions. Plus it looks like the about half the pledges are for a new "secret project" and not the fancy edition, which is even less niche. Those people just have to be Brandon...

Looks promising. But still no Ron Perlman Voice over? That seems like such a no brainer.

Keep in mind that it's a pretty abbreviated description of events. There's probably a lot more details that might have prompted. The thing I odd is that it seems like the SRD De authorization debacle is a major component, but that's been resolved now. I think there's probably just a lot of bad...

I think there's really two issues: verisimilitude and interesting combat encounters. On the verisimilitude angle, I don't have any issue with it, for all the reasons other people have mentioned. From the combat encounter angle though, I can see it being a problem. If it's just one encounter...

@evilhat Thanks for stopping by the forums to answer questions. I've never played any of the Tomb Raider games, but Evil Hat being involved means that I might check it out.

In addition to the technical difference people have mentioned, another element is that random generators are never going to put anybody out of a job. We're already seeing companies use AI art in their products, and AI writing is all over clickbait sites. AI writing isn't good enough to replace...

I voted for the ones that are absolute red flags for me, like use of AI and poor creator track record. There are others that I didn't vote for that aren't absolute deal breakers, but make me less likely to buy something. For instance I mostly buy PDFs, but every once in a while I get something...

Usually the GM says, "Hey, this is something I'm interested in running," and then the players say. "Sure, that sounds great, we just want to play!"

Or the designers didn't think it was wise it to include a bunch of high-level monsters when the rules for characters only went up to 3rd level (At least in 1983 version, I never had the '81). I think dragons only made the cut because they were in the name of the game.

I assume the poll is "When you want to use 3PP content, how often is it allowed." Players don't ask often, but when they do it's normally allowed, so I voted frequently.

We've hit another stretch goal, for a second book: 20 Vibrant Vestments! Now all backers get this second ebook for free! The campaign ends tomorrow, so the time to back is now! Plus we've got one final item preview featuring the ring of charity.