Maxperson's latest activity

Hello folks. I have something to add. There is an argument being presented that it is not meaningful to ask "what would have happened on...

I was about to answer this when @The Firebird fully invalidated my answer by giving a much better answer. Thank you so much for sharing!!

Get off of his game. We aren't talking about his game. We are discussing the difference in playstyles. In yours you don't know. In...

Wrong post

I've answered this twice now and you'll get to those posts shortly I think. :P

YOU don't know. WE know. If the guard would hear a singing failure, he also hears a singing success. He is in the same spot. The...

When @AlViking asks him what happens when.... It's from the perspective of his playstyle. He's really saying, "This wouldn't work for...

I.e. if you vote red you are not voting for a different alternative, you are voting to get nothing at all. If you would prefer it done...

Hear, Hear!

As GM I want my players to succeed most of the time. They won't succeed 100% of the time at everything they try. As GM I want to...

See my above post to @Hussar. What the players do will often cut down or even eliminate checks altogether. If they can describe to me...

It really depends on how the players play the game. If they are trying to be quiet when they enter, a single stealth check will cover...

First, the combat rules can't really be used as any sort of indication for the use or lack of use of the principle. The combat rules use...

I agree.

I like it (pardon the pun). What it saves are hundreds of posts sayng nothing but "I agree" or "Hear, hear!".