Maxperson's latest activity

(y) I try to run my games that way. There may be times where I mess that up, but I try to give as many details as I can about the...

Oh it may even have been me! I have no doubt that it was brought up. I just don’t know in what context, or who brought it up first and...

Metacurrencies are often considered narrative, because you use them not to do the best manipulation of the rules (which would be...

Hawkeye > Green Arrow, but Batman > Hawkeye. Sorry.

You might be reading more into that than is there. I think(and I could be wrong) that he's saying that a DM who changes the fiction on...

Sure, and those are the minority of complications. Skill does play a part in those, but most of the time complications crop up...

You don't get to make it irrelevant, though. To a lot of us it's very relevant. You can that you don't find it relevant, but that's...

I'm not going back multiple hundreds of pages to show you that I'm still saying the exact same thing that I've said several times. It's...

On the fly =/= added retroactively, though. If I narrate to the group that the cliff face is rough and made of decaying granite...

Then you can count me in that number as well, although it depends on the check. Previous versions had this a bit more spelled out that...

Probably because the player's action itself wasn't the driving force, it was the die result, so it's more mechanics/system-driven.

I'm drawing a parallel between dismissals of player guided exploration as "mere color" and the no true Scottsman dismissal of...

I’m not sure what you mean here. I think I’m pointing out that the specifics of the example can place the crumbling rocks either above...

I don't agree with that. With all kinds of things, and not just RPGs, folks are okay dealing with parts of something one way, but not...

no, you misunderstand, i said i would never change the state of the fiction in response to a check, if the wall is solid it's solid, if...