Maxperson's latest activity

In your terms, always static. Otherwise, you're looking at a skill/DC increase treadmill. What's the point of increasing your skill if...

This came up in he Daggerheart General thread and I thought I would move it to its own thread for discussion. In games that havel...

100% static. The difficulty for climbing a specific rock face isn't going to change depending on who is climbing it. It's going to be...

Frankly, your stance on edition naming is bonkers and unmoored from reality. There are countless things where different editions of a...

Not what is called D&D. What IS D&D.

I'm just saying that not all opinions are correct. In this case WotC gets to be the one to decide if it's the same game or not, and...

And there we are. All the game engines of them seemed vastly more similar than different to me.

Answer is "It depends." You'd need to rework some elements of some of them, but they have the same criteria I'm using: structural, look...

Oh yes, GW has never published RPGs or had editions of those RPGs not be compatible. Never ever. Jesus murphy.

500 people attended the first flat earth conference. Having others believe what you believe doesn't make it the belief correct.

Different iterations of the same game. And it's not just RPGs. Windows 11 is very different from Windows 95, yet they are all called...

Like how you think that iterations of game that aren't compatible aren't the same game. Our hobby is littered with game iterations that...

There's not enough money to make it worthwhile, and they might even lose money supporting prior editions. Far better to open those...

I think they should be supporting all the prior editions, so sure, why not?

I think they are iterations of the same game. Some I like better than others, but yes, 4E is D&D in my opinion even if I don't much care...