Micah Sweet's latest activity

I think if two people are using two different definitions of a word, then I'm not sure can say they have to deal with consequences of...

You are wrong. That is not what it means. All it means is that all the power rests in the hands of one. It does not mean he doesn't...

That "declares" step can come after discussion, however; and in fact must if the discussion otherwise ends in a stalemate. It's when...

Thanks. Sometimes I forget the original point of this mega-thread was to rag on trad-leaning players in their own forum.

In your games, is it wrong for a player to say "rocks fall, Greg's character dies" without any prompt or a roll? I'm assuming so; it is...

Never said you did either of those things. But not doing either is IMO required for people with different opinions about the same topic...

So it's ok for me not to like something you like, but it's not ok for me to explain why I don't like it? That seems strange to me.

Oh I don't agree. The GM does not have a comparable role to a player in a conventional game, certainly not in trad play. If the GM is...

I've not seen this in the thread. I'll say it here and now: your tastes are reasonable and fun! It's nice that your style of gaming...

Not true. You're welcome to enjoy or not enjoy any style of gaming you want. Just don't try to claim objective superiority of what you...

Given that in-fiction there's no such thing as class abilties, feats, etc... the premise is nonsensical.

Why would you say that? You are representing those in-fiction abilities as game mechanics.

This claim isn't true at all, in my view. Trying to infer to social life from nothing but archaeological information is very fraught.

Given the amount of complaining about trad GMs (and trad GM playstyles) from the Narrativists on this thread, I really don't find my...

They seemed to weather that ok.