Micah Sweet's latest activity

Good one. I'll concede there's another WotC out there, albeit for minis games rather than RPGs. GW has always been the WotC of minis...

I think to a large extent OD&D to AD&D 2.0 are different variations of the same game. I think after that each full edition change is...

I agree. 2e and 3e are definitely different games, just like 3e, 4e, and 5e are all different games.

Yeah, if RAW doesn't make sense to me, I just change the rules.

I know OP is looking for a RAW answer, the best I can do is try to see between the RAW lines since they're not too specific. Remember...

Sure, but I can't speak from anyone else's perspective than my own, and neither can you. Can you give me an example of incompatible...

Like what?

the added line of "access to a forge" implies smith's tools don't include one (which the tool description says outright)...so i'd...

I don't know how compatible different versions of Runequest are from each other. How does it compare to 3e, 4e, and 5e versus the...

Fair enough. To me, any game that incompatible with another without major work is a different game, no matter what name it carries.

I do this too, but the roll also builds in things like "did anything major go wrong with the ship itself, or did anything else happen to...

My son doesn't care for TTRPGs and prefer video games of various stripes. My daughter lives D&D but has social anxiety and has a hard...

I don't think so, no, but as I said smith tools aren't of much use without a way to heat the metal, and the basic components of a forge...

Ok. One last question. Do you believe all versions of D&D are basically the same game?

Good lord. OK. Let's just move on here, I think we've beaten this horse to death a couple of times over now.