Micah Sweet's latest activity

You said that good speech would still be reflective of a low Charisma somehow. I don't understand that.

That doesn't have anything to do with what ability scores are defined as, however.

Lack of 1 particular choice, especially for a particular aesthetic reason, isn’t railroading.

Why wouldn't that penalty be reflected in behavior bad speech equals lack of success, at least most of the time. For it to be...

Why not?

Modifiers IMO aren't enough if the stats present themselves as part of the character's definition. Look at those name. Those are...

I don't know what this means. Please assume I both speak and listen literally unless I suggest otherwise.

Sure, but I wouldn't really like to see a lot of physical grace from a character with a 6 Dex either.

Tell me why they're there then. Are they intended as nothing more than modifiers to specific die rolls? They're not everything of...

The idea behind the system is If you are not proficient with a skill and you roll exceptionally well, perhaps beating another who is...

I think it's unlikely this would ever be an issue unless there was a pretty big, obvious gap between the behavior and the stat on the...

Yes, if you had a low Dex I would want to see that come out in role-playing. Why wouldn't I?

Coming up with that story is roleplaying their PC.

Well...I would not want to play with a table or a player that is not open to new ideas, is GM antagonistic, immature or selfish. In the...

You can't ignore it on die rolls without cheating. Not the same thing.