Micah Sweet's latest activity

That's an issue of Charisma being too broadly defined to make logical sense, or a mistake in having it be mechanically important to...

Never saw it. Can't answer without seeing the character in action.

I'm not. But I am questioning why someone wouldn't do so.

All of these assume the only purpose of Int is to provide modifiers to certain dice rolls.

In a group where everyone feels that way it is probably highly unlikely that the GM would actually need to veto anything, as the players...

I'm not insisting on anything. I'm saying ignoring your stats in terms of roleplay makes zero sense to me.

So what does that mean Charisma is? Just a die modifier? I don't think so.

I think this discussion is actually about immersion for some folks -- the dumb PC coming up with smart ideas by way of the player breaks...

You said that good speech would still be reflective of a low Charisma somehow. I don't understand that.

That doesn't have anything to do with what ability scores are defined as, however.

Lack of 1 particular choice, especially for a particular aesthetic reason, isn’t railroading.

Why wouldn't that penalty be reflected in behavior bad speech equals lack of success, at least most of the time. For it to be...

Why not?

Modifiers IMO aren't enough if the stats present themselves as part of the character's definition. Look at those name. Those are...

I don't know what this means. Please assume I both speak and listen literally unless I suggest otherwise.