Minigiant's latest activity

The evidence is the point that these settings put the non-humans in Nations that are out of the way and also make their populations...

My point is that they aren't supposed to. That's why these setting hide their nonhuman people away and have their people not travel.

The issue isn't having human nations for human players. The silly part is adding elven, dwarven, orcish etc nations and shoving them in...

90% of those dwarfs and elves are PCS. The premise behind old school D&D, tokenesque settings, and setting described in this very...

I'm not saying you can't make an RPG with tolkienesqe specieses. What I am saying is that it is objectively a bad idea to design a game...

No. It's stating for what D&D is... Tolkienesqe Nonhuman Nations are objectively bad ideas if players are supposed to play and roleplay...

Every elf life is precious and rare. Elves don't have many babies. Elf spend most of their time doing manual tasks and not evolving...

And my point is that's good ideas for a book. It's a terrible idea for a violent dungeoneering RPG. We are just used to it and...

Perhaps there are several levels of Human Centric Fantasy Settings Human Only There are only Humans Human Majority Humans are the...

That's adventurers The issue is these nations of ancient races where no one ever leaves and the people do nothing nor leave or 500...

Well what i mean by "strong excuse" is an excuse that is somewhat tangible and visible in the setting AND more importantly useful for...

One thing that sort of traditional fantasy has leaned into is the notion of segregation. You have the "elf lands" "dwarf lands" etc...

Not only that, every elf teen in many settings is trained in a class. And every dwarf teen is indoctrinated to love hammers and axes...

That's still ~90 years with a full adult body and being treated like a child. I dunno. 90 years is a long time. Especially if the...

As elf spends from 12 to 110 as teenager, i think they are sexed out after nearly 90 years.