Minigiant's latest activity

I don't mind Monks, but a 6e monk should be pulling concepts from Cradle, xianxia fiction, Street Fighter, WoW and Diablo, not from...

Fighter don't need to be wuxia. Fighters do need to be able to level powerwise to an Archmage. Just how Barbarians with enough levels...

I understand that. My point is it's all the same system just different slices of it. You can just cut off the slice that you want...

I'm not saying RPGs is just math. I'm saying that a fighter, cleric, and elf in every edition are on the same line. Just at different...

Yes Numbers and rider effects. Going from +2 to hit. 1d6+2 damage to +8 to hit, 3d6+4 damage + Prone or 4d8+4 damage It's just...

Human nature.

It's literally just level ranges. Dandy fans have no problem categorizing what power level a magical effect is within the number range...

It's not that crazy YEs I've played other RPGs. You do realize every version of D&D uses the same resolution system as the main...

I do. A Shadowdark fighter is just numbers go up. You can put that beside a 4E weaponmaster and a 3e wizard. Just get the number right.

What I am saying those style of play are not incompatible. They are different set of classes and species at different levels.

Yes. You do.

We do all want the same 6e. Just different level ranges of it. That's the problem. Everyone fights to stretch their preferred level...

You can hit all the power everyone wants in 35 levels. But some groups will start at level 1, some level 10, some level -3, and some...

I don't want to be mean to designers here, but it is striking that certain aspects of D&D, especially in 3E and 5E (4E was pretty wild)...

Bingo!