Minigiant's latest activity

Who cares there's a fix somewhere when 3/4 of GMs don't know it's there, 3/4 of those who do will refuse to ever even consider using it...

It can... But it would end up like the game Battle Brothers where everyone is wielding a spear or pike.

One of my gripes with bounded accuracy is that larger weapons should have a bonus to attack rolls and AC. Like +1 for longswords and...

Not IMO. I think barbarian should be a subclass or feat chain under the fighter class. But I think we only need 3-4 classes: Warrior /...

it's a nice overview and attempt to merge reality with gameplay logics and that it does not need to meet 100% of the time. also I agree...

That's the other reason why I want the 4th book. I want there to be both the option for DMs to hand out pre-made legacy items, roll or...

If you cut spells you can fit the illusionist and Necromancer :whistle:

You replace them with more important stuff In the PHB More subclasses More subraces More feats More backgrounds More equipment in the...

The old way does already because it shoves bigger more important content in supplements My way, you get 6-8 subclasses per class, more...

I still think the PHB has too many spells and the DMG has too many items hogging up pages. Like the PHB wizard spell list should go old...

The other thing about old-school play, in generalized terms anyway, is that things are somewhat swingier. A supposedly tough challenge...

No. 3 books you all the basics The 4 book is like 4-5 supplements worth of stuff. Shove the Apparatus of Kwalish and all those...

Okay maybe not traps Players Handbook Species Classes Feats Necessary Core Spells (Fireball, Magic Missile, Read Magic, Hunter's...

Nah. Just cut the magic spells and items and traps to its own book. Create space in the PHB and DMG for more stuff.

Personally you can't do all three in one book due to how big and diverse the D&D customer base is. That's why I'd make a 4th book and...