Minigiant's latest activity

Hey. That's giving a reason. My setting has cat people because of a Credit card commercial. War kittens??!!! gimme a reason. It can...

Nah. The part many people don't get is, there's a lot of lame or poorly made homegrown settings out there that run on friendship or the...

Aragorn isnt a D&D ranger as they have existed for the last 25+ years. Probably longer. Middle Earth is clearly not in line with D&D's...

Then the player is lying or hiding their reason and doesn't get to be a tortle.

My point is that's not a valid core unless you are a child. You must have a reason to be tortle.

The valid reasons are that you can't make believe of it or it makes the game unfun. But you have to be able to describe why.

I am a deep roleplayer as a DM. I roleplay elves like hundred year old magicians and dwarves like people who see in the dark and don't...

Nah. Lack of compromise is fine if you have valid reasons.

People who don't engage in either direction are problematic. Players and DMs both need to step up and explain their thought processes...

Lack of compromise itself is not a red flag. Lack of compromise without describing or explaining why one won't compromise is a red flag.

Remember that it's New Years, and you shouldn't break your resolutions until at least the third week of January. Weird. That sounds...

The hypothetical player mentioned say "No I want X". When I ask posters if the player was asked or can describe why they want X, they...

If somebody wants to play a particular aspect as a class or a race but can't tell you why they wanna play that class or race either...

A point I can certainly grant. By that same token, however, this example kinda gives a good reason why leaning toward inclusive, even if...

Methinks you are forgetting where D&D started from - modelling Tolkien. None of those critters existed in OD&D. But races/classes and...