mixmastashizz's latest activity

I think you underestimate how many people roleplay without speaking in the third person or using a funny voice.

Then my question is the same: What is functionally the difference between a player saying to the group "Trolls are weak to fire" and...

Then I will tell you again I'm sorry you've had such a terrible experience in the hobby, because I simply will not assume the worst as...

Let the record show that I don't think that Warlocks should have a patron. Instead, I think that the Warlock should regularly be making...

I don't want to badger any player, but part of the class narrative of the class the player chose is that they receive their power...

My feeling is, if you don’t want the possibility of that kind of story (where the fiction of the pact matters) don’t play a warlock. At...

This is true for most players, and not just about Warlock Pacts. Players hate the idea that the DM can force their character to do...

Any time someone told me that 3d6 was the "intended" way to generate characters, I'd just grab any 1e module with pre-generated...

Idk why you'd need to even do that. You can just show them the PHB and the DMG and tell them to read two pages where it says not to!

I think its okay to think torches are cool. Just because something is old doesnt mean that it isn't cool or aesthetically pleasing. I...

Come on now, every gamer can quote Monty Python and the Holy Grail. And Spaceballs. And the Princess Bride.

80% of my players are under 40, and quote Monty Python fairly regularly. Although that may say more about my players and my game than...

Okay ill respond to this one. Does your attitude on this topic assume that players ARENT working together and ARENT sharing information...

I think you're making a pretty large leap. Would you punish a player for saying "Hey we need fire to kill the troll!" the first time...

I was saying that there's effectively no difference between what you called metagaming and saying "you know basic facts about dnd...