I won't argue 2E.
4E seems pretty clear though if you have Manual of the Planes. Either the book is badly written, or Sigil was changed.
Page 9 says "Sigil is a recursive demiplane. The city fills the interior of a torus, so a traveler can’t help but circle back to where he started by...
So 4E Sigil is fully enclosed and there is a strong case that original Sigil might be too? Interesting but in all honesty most groups are going to play it the way they feel like, anyway, so I doubt it matters too much. Anyway I have got my answer about doughnuts from a maths site.
[edit] 2E has...
Call me an idiot but i am not exactly sure that band around the middle in the picture is an open space. According to the text, you're supposed to be able to walk around the whole city and return to your start point from a straight line, and onyl way to do that would be to walk around the inside...
From your answers I can see that you haven't seen that Sigil has changed in 4E. I am asking about the 4E version of it. In the 4E Planes book page 25 "The city is built on the inside of gigantic hollow ring that has no outside". Picture on page 27 shows the city wrapping around the inside of the...
Just reading the new 4E Manual of the Planes. Came across this:
"Sigil is a recursive demiplane. The city fills the interior of a torus, so a traveler can’t help but circle back to where he started by continuing in a straight line."
So they are saying that if I were to walk in a straight line...
I love you even if you are the classic donkey. You made me remember the good old days and cry, from when we played in uni. Hours long fights against epic dudes who didn't hold back and would kill you - all of you - if you made just one mistake, because the DM ran them like a PC. There was no...