Recent content by Mustrum_Ridcully

  1. Mustrum_Ridcully

    Let's talk about system options versus character options.

    A system with classes seems to automatically come with some abilities only being character options, not system options. But even there, you can obviously have some "system options" like maybe everyone can attempt to disarm a foe or push someone away. The example of 3E with system options that...
  2. Mustrum_Ridcully

    Why do so many campaigns never finish? Genuinely curious what others think

    I am not even sure it's a burnout, or just "new shiny". I experience that as a player, too, wanting to play a different character because I have found some new interesting character concept or powergaming fantasy or whatever, and so one character gets retired. And such retired characters can...
  3. Mustrum_Ridcully

    City Supplements - What do we like?

    That is probably very sensible, but some might feel the urge to have a city that is useable as main adventure place for level 1-20. But that might just be asking too much from a single city. This is probably an issue a game like Shadowrun can avoid - the characters just don't "level" in a way...
  4. Mustrum_Ridcully

    City Supplements - What do we like?

    What are "core NPCs" for you? Important characters in the city? NPC stats can be important to get some guidlines on how the players can fit in the world. If your major NPCs are mostly CR 15+ stats that is quite different frm them being CR5. In the latter, a level 10 adventuring party might...
  5. Mustrum_Ridcully

    D&D 5E (2024) Unfreezing the Narrative

    Draw Steel! does this - you have 3 possible results, I don't remember the exact terminology, but you can get either a weak, average, or good result. Even a poor result deals some "damage", because someone coming at you with a weapon might miss, but you needed to expend some effort to deflect...
  6. Mustrum_Ridcully

    Homebrew Whacky Half-Formed Idea for Armor as DR...

    1d4 -> 1d3 (1d6 / 2) -> 1d2 (coin or 1d4/2 or 1d6/3) -> 1d1 (e.g. minimum 1 point). I think since armor doesn't negate all damage, no skill needs to circumvent armor, unless there is a special class ability priced in as some armor-defeating ability. But that would be the same as any ability...
  7. Mustrum_Ridcully

    Homebrew Whacky Half-Formed Idea for Armor as DR...

    The advantage of basically adjusting the weapon die step by step is that it solves the issue that low damage attacks can be negated by other forms of DR. But since it's not a fixed value, you still roll some damage, this problem is avoided. (for that; I'd definitely set some lower bound, it...
  8. Mustrum_Ridcully

    City Supplements - What do we like?

    Though a wee map could make a nice visualization tool. Bu there are of course also challenges, where does it fit in the layout, how large does it have to be to be readable/fillable, especially given the shape of the wards... On the challenges of making a city work as adventuring place: I...
  9. Mustrum_Ridcully

    D&D 5E (2024) This Feels Like 4E

    Amusingly, I remember a concept of a golfcart of weapons in 3E. You needed a Silver weapon to deal with enemies that had DR/Silver, and cold iron weaons for enemies that had DR/cold iron. And it was also a good idea to carry some Admantine weapon so you have an enhancement bonus against DR/+1...
  10. Mustrum_Ridcully

    D&D 3.x [3.PF] "Restricted Gestalt" Variants

    That's why I thought why it was a good potential match for d20, that you only pick the better characteristic. I think my only worry would be that it might still be too straightforward (take Strong for full BAB and Smart for full skill points. The Tough hit points just aren't as valuable as the...
  11. Mustrum_Ridcully

    Let's Talk About Core Game Mechanics

    One thing I am considering for 2d10 or 2d6 roll systems: If you get the same number twice, it's considered some kind of crit. Whatever that would mean, exactly, remains to be decided. (Of course, that still means the highest number is the best, obviously, but you might get a more spectacular...
  12. Mustrum_Ridcully

    D&D 3.x [3.PF] "Restricted Gestalt" Variants

    I always felt that there might be a bit too many imbalanced combinations, but maybe that isn't a real problem if you're considering them in the first place. However, I also always thought it woud be nice to use this approach to d20 Modern. Possibly with the requirement that you must pick one...
  13. Mustrum_Ridcully

    D&D 5E (2024) This Feels Like 4E

    I can't speak for others than myself, but I have an idea what it might be... Tactics in 3E were ... well, maybe not tactics at all, and more like strategy or logistics? Working out which buff spells t use and when, how to max out on the different bonus types (and avoiding, but definitely...
  14. Mustrum_Ridcully

    D&D General Warlocks' patrons vs. Paladin Oaths and Cleric Deities

    That cannot really be true, because attacks in the real world can happen in less than 6 seconds, or multiple blows can be done in 6 seconds or less. There is still no way to link a single attack roll to one specific "swing".
  15. Mustrum_Ridcully

    What videogames are you playing in 2026?

    Isn't that Saint Rows IV? Maybe? Depending on what of the GTA V experience you mean specifically. I preferred Saint Rows III, though, it was over-the-top, but in a more charming way, IMO. --- I am currently playing "The Last Starship". It's close to an idea for a kind of video game I wanted to...
Top