Neonchameleon's latest activity

Yes, absolutely, I've been making this point in multiple posts throughout this thread. The idea that (say) Moldvay Basic and Apocalypse...

Yeah, I do find the argument that we can't have player-driven play, because it excludes player B when the focus is on player A's...

Meaning magic items should be less +X and more turning weapon or spell damage to another damage types or giving new language or some...

And there's something we can agree on :)

Which of my groups? My main historic 4e group has one member dead and another in another part of the country. My most recent 4e group...

Their reply was a clear call back to that, but can we maybe not relitigate it? Im actually curious about what somebody who tried both...

What actually happened was I pointed out that DH was a better Grimdark game than DH and provided a reason why. You apparently found a...

Where "a very small minority" is just about every table I have played with as player or GM. I wonder what I was doing that you aren't.

There is some pretty intense irony here when you tried desperately to prove in this thread that 5e was as good at being GrimDark as...

The thing here is that there are mechanics that can encourage story and mechanics that can harm story, and this is independent of...

With respect, improv GMing within a collaborative table framework is far more adaptable and easy to run then something like a...

Except it didn't fall apart in reality in 4e IME but does in 5e. That's because 4e gave ways of working together that 5e doesn't have -...

4e gave answers. 1e and 3e gave the answer but hid it in another answer. So if you ignored the Magic Item Tables or Wealth by Level...

Actually good (interesting) Devil's Bargains are often outside the scope of the score, ideally wrapping in factions or Rivals/Allies and...

This prompted me to look at the SRD on Devil's Bargains: PCs in Blades are reckless scoundrels addicted to destructive vices—they don’t...