Pedantic's latest activity

You'd at least need a sharply finite number of possible answers for it to be useful.

I can give some individual suggestions when the topic and game systems is at hand, but I can't say I have a general principal beyond...

Yeah, I agree. He's way better with more time to breathe. Worlds Beyond Number is definitely his best work, and it's no surprise it's...

Hmm, maybe. The stuff I like about him is his worldbuilding, which -- per behind the scenes videos on Dropout -- he puts months of work...

Controversial, but I think Mulligan is only okay live. You can see him ripping rules off the system in real time, and it suffers for it.

Yeah, licensed games live or die by their licenses. I'm sure there are people out there still playing the Buffy RPG, but once all of the...

I immediately thought of Star Wars Saga Edition. A pretty big release in 2007, but ended abruptly in 2010 and lost a lot of players...

Perhaps some reframing of what part of the game loop is actually being engaged is relevant here. Players basically do two things: ask...

Combat is actually an interesting counter point, precisely because it's always a timer. Assuming a standard battle without extra win...

If I understand correctly, it's a change to the information and/or decision space. In past threads that's sometimes been overlooked. I...

I'm mostly hoping this means a lot more content comes out to support Daggerheart. I didn't immediately love it, but there's nothing...

In the chain I was responding to, it appeared that player interest might have been proposed as a divider. Supposing that Stormbringer...

I just don't see it. You could maybe make a case for less daily resources? Late 3e was mostly marked by experimentation with resource...

I was absolutely paying attention to those changes, and I don't at all agree. An alternative development path that worked to address...

In my post I did acknowledge that there is a connection between system and interest. (Horse color table do not really help much for...