Pedantic's latest activity

I don't see a compelling reason this needs to go either way. Your case here doesn't suggest the GM has actually done any world building...

I think the switch to acending AC probably qualifies here. It's undoubtedly simpler to operate and it doesn't sacrifice any granularity...

You can lead a gamer to mountain dew, but you cant make them drink. Some folks simply do not want to drive the game. As much as folks...

I think we'll need to be deliberate and specific in order to have a useful discussion here. People are throwing adjectives around like...

It's very clear at this point that no one is winning anything here. :p

I'm going to go through this again. When someone wants something as a player, there is likely a minimum element that needs to be...

That's not exactly what I meant, and I think my description is colored by all the board game design I've been doing lately. The whole...

I don't think it's at all extreme to say "I've had enough running D&D for a while. So if you don't want to play Star Wars and would...

Obligatory:

I asked my friend the other day if the coffee he'd given me was a natural process (he's normally a dark roast guy and I was surprised to...

Bob seems to be one of these people who confuses being "nice" with being "good."

Woah! That's a lot of steps to walk from where I'm at, not the least because I'm not especially storytelling inclined. If I had a strong...

Interesting. My goals as a player are entirely different from yours. I don't want to "tell my story about my character." (If I wanted to...

I continue to be sad I mentioned tortles. Setting that aside, there's clearly a norm at stake here that I don't think is reconcilable...

For a lot of cases with a setting, it may be one that's been run with before - just with a new set of players for a new campaign...