pemerton's latest activity

This is fail forward. You continue to ignore clarifications on what fail forward means and instead continue to work with your flawed...

Yes, I find that equally ridiculous. The characters in most of my narrativist games tend to be at least as substantive as any in my trad...

And again, you're out of your depth. You have clearly never participated in Narrativist play, as your characterization of how it works...

I don't know BitD or Vampire well-enough to answer. I've GMed a fair bit of Classic Traveller over the past several years. I think it...

I may or may not. I mean, as has been discussed, failure on a climb check could mean a number of things. So, if a PC falls, they may...

Tuovineni is a self-identified lover of simulationism. He doesn't reject himself! I am a self-identified simulationist, in that I have...

Yes, it is a change. It's not a direct violation of the integrity of the roll, though. This is a perfectly valid way to handle the...

As I've posted not far upthread, the player doesn't decide what the runes say.

Even this is not quite correct. The player said, as their PC, "I will try and decipher these runes, hoping that they will reveal a way...

You have attributed something to @hawkeyefan which I said. And the reason I spoke about MHRP/Cortex+ Fantasy Heroic is because that was...

Huh? It seems to me pointless to try and talk about "PbtA" as a class. That would be liking talking about all games that involve...

If a player has to first sort of explore the setting through their character and often will have to engage in unrelated matters to...

It was @TheFirebird who introduced the discussion of "winning", not me, and who suggested that the players in the games I've posted...

It seems obvious to me that if the GM embodies the setting, the players are not at full liberty to set their own goals. Or...

This is not correct. The player expressed a hope for what the runes said. Dice were then rolled, and that hope came true. Saying that...