pemerton's latest activity

I don't remember arguing for the system to change. I'm arguing for specific interpretations of the system, in ways I've found to...

"Neotrad" is a perfectly acceptable term. You've read the 6 Cultures article, right? Not to mention I clarified the meaning I was...

I've had players completely rebuild characters from the ground up (new race and class) due to events within the campaign. To my mind...

But there aren't thousands PCs in the campaign world. There are only a few dozens at best (sometimes single digits only even!), even in...

I have actually been known to change players' subclasses on them as a consequence. But I have two hard rules: Not without the consent...

I don't see a design problem. These issues only seemed to get raised around classes like cleric, paladin, and (now) warlock. I don't...

That kinda evoked an image that maybe you didn't mean to evoke?

It's a misstatement of the rules? The rules you posted literally say this: "This is possible only if there are currently fewer than...

Maybe that player was suffering from main character syndrome?

Perfectly fine, but we're at the point were I hope everyone can agree that classes are player-facing, not in-world constructs in 5e...

I'm assuming chocolate-strawberry-death bans multiclassing for the realism.

As one of the vehement posters, I would point out that "GM shouldn't limit player choice" and "worldbuilding belongs exclusively to the...

It's not really the transformation that's problematic. It isn't even really about invoking a consequence. It's more about the idea...

Glad I can play a Barlock in your table

But none of those characters exist together. We’re not doing the Lanefan thing where everyone’s setting is connected to everyone else’s.