Pvt. Winslow's latest activity

Meanwhile if you go by actual play in vaguely skilled hands 4e had in many ways the strongest non-combat game of any D&D edition unless...

It's incredible how misconceptions still abound for basic things about 4e.

The most basic answer is that RPGs came out of tabletop war games, which were inherently turn based. I suppose you could call that...

Well combat - or any situation where a lot of very important actions are happening in rapid succession, and the order in which they...

I just don't see how you can see the "Sharing the Spotlight" section and "Engage Quiet Players" and think it doesn't apply to all scenes...

A) Daggerheart fundamentally disagrees with your point. It expects the GM to actively pull the players, all of them, into the game. This...

Well that just isn’t true. Since when do clerics have a remit of spreading their god’s faith? Defend the faithful, fight the forces...

This is literally the first time I have ever seen or heard clerics and paladins referred to as "jihadists" and frankly it feels like...

I've done this in my games. Some bosses get one or two doom points (I call them "dreadful blessings" in my game and they're usually tied...

I don't follow how this would somehow be more reasonable. If there is anything less fun than having the wizard eliminate a lieutenant...

Call it what you want, but I have never seen a table benefit from spot nerfing or revenge fudging.

Nothing promotes reasonable discussion quite like name calling.

I find D&D far better at generating stories than generating fair and balanced encounters. Some of the most memorable moments in the game...

If only a version of D&D had been published that did all this!

That just exacerbates the faulty D&D design of higher level casters having essentially useless low level slots. Really casting needs a...