Recent content by Rack

So he has the worst combat abilities in the game (comparable attack to non-fighters and zero defence), can save a few copper pieces on torches and has detect magic? What exactly would you consider underpowered, would he literally have to save or die every hour to keep breathing?

We aren't designers here, we're testers. They aren't going to want more qualitative feedback than they can use in 10 lifetimes, just basic patterns of what people liked and didn't.

Advantage is a pretty big deal, so I'd only offer it in situations where the defender was pretty much incapable of defending himself, just one measure short of an auto-hit.