Remathilis's latest activity

Sure, some like DS and DL (which are curated settings), but others like GH and FR that have always accommodated additions (whether from...

To a point, I agree. We wont see eye to eye on this though so, have a good rest of your day.

I mean, when Eberron came out, it was touted as a setting designed for modern (WotC) era D&D, which at the time meant magic shops and...

I think it's more a notion of emphasis. If I was making a setting designed explicitly to emphasize the new elements, those are what I...

I think the following: Orcs as PC species rather than antagonist monsters Lore changes to monsters who has their types changed...

I was responding to Scribe's comment about older settings not being changed or retconned. Which I find to be both impossible (if they...

I like Rising from the Last War's explanation for the sudden proliferation of Dragonborn: most Humans still think they are Lizardfolk...

What's funny is there is an explicit mention of there being "half-dragon lizard folk" of Q'barra in the 3e Eberron book, but some people...

Older settings never worked that way. PC races, classes etc where added to the game in Dragon Magazine, Unearthed Arcana etc, and they...

That's as maybe, but the statement from the OP was... Unless, in the intervening posts (which I did not read comprehensively), it has...

I'm responding to the notion older settings cannot be used if changes to them have to be made to make them compatible with the current...

Right. IMHO there are two different types of settings in D&D: kitchen sink and curated. Greyhawk, Realms, Eberron, Spelljammer...

Not gonna lie - a Xarfell Fyrepriest just on name alone sounds kinda awesome! 😂

It’s not irrelevant. There was no real reason given in the lore of the settings for why demihumans had these limitations. It was simply...

So every edition you throw out all the lore and start fresh? That's IP suicide! I understand you hate D&D, but you're asking an...