Remathilis's latest activity

Outside of a few super-specific campaign elements outside their respective settings (Dragonmarks in Eberron, Dark Gifts in Ravenloft) I...

I have never mistaken ban lists for coherency, distinctiveness, or shapefulness. The vast majority of banlists are all about keeping...

That's how most fantasy writers who aren't called Tolkien work. The world starts out largely formless. As their protagonists move...

Then, isn't that a pretty solid reason to have a new setting that is distinct? That draws on D&D as it is now and not D&D as it was...

You are quite willing, but plenty of DMs aren't. Look how many people resist the idea of refluffing Dragonborn and Goliaths as dray and...

That still requires the DM to look at the subclass and create whole new lore for it. Lots of DMs simply won't. And to be fair, they...

Brad and Janet 😉

Not at all. I'm saying that if Microsoft made a bunch of different and vaguely compatible versions of Windows and then tried to support...

Heck, never minding homebrewing, even in published settings, different tables interpret the setting totally differently. Just this week...

Again, isn't focusing on a single setting precisely what they did for most of 5e? Outside of a few other AP's, virtually every book for...

BIrthright 2027

It does create a very arbitrary line when one thing is generic enough to be in the PHB (Knowledge domain) but shunted off to the...

i think the issue they were getting at is more GMs approving or denying the use of game components based on mostly arbitrary lines of...

Because you get dumb ideas like bladesinger and knowledge clerics locked in a Faerun book and half-elves khoravar and artificers locked...

Those people ignore it like they ignore Golarion or Midguard. But the game itself builds upon that lore and everything is compatible...