Remathilis's latest activity

My guess is that people here are taking that personally because D&D is a personal endeavor. If you invited me to play a video game with...

I'll be blunt: I have stated repeatedly that I have a standard I hold for new games I'm joining: no options less than what the core...

I think we’re talking past each other. In this instance, the knight is not even a guard captain, he’s a guard. A flunky. The stat block...

COnan-esque game but no one is human and based on Japanese myth.

Yeah I know, but you keep trying to convince me that your carefully created vision is Good Actually even though I've said its too...

Player: Cool. No beasts, no undead, no demons, no aberrations. DM: Whoa whoa whoa: you can't expect me to not have cultists summoning...

I find it hilarious that that's all I've ever argued and people keep insisting I'm forcing DMs to bend to my whims. Are DMs such...

Like I've said, it's principle. If you are removing my options without considering alternatives, how about I do the same for you? Let me...

Ok, so we're talking minimums again. Which is more than the minimum. Which actually wasn't my point. My point was Shadowdark has 6...

This is a D&D general thread about a blogger lamenting the changes in 5e 2024. So of all editions 5e 2024 does have special weight here

I'm actually someone that'd more than willing to reshape my character concept for the campaign, but I find that the contemporary play...

Well considering your Platonic Ideal, what was next was banning four species and eight classes, so I think my judgment call was spot on.

Well, by MY standard, which Scribe was disagreeing with, you're fine. You limited two options but replaced them with four, two of which...

As I just recently mentioned in the "why do you play games that aren't D&D" thread, I actually think D&D has always done a very poor job...

Sure. But the discussion is on DMs creating personal settings that have ultra-narrow themes that might lock out types of PCs from creation.