Remathilis's latest activity

Your D&D isn't mine yes. This whole thing is about how we'd hate if our D&D meets-up.

You did not ask me, but yes, plenty are. But it's not a simple "oh yes that's always 100% safe" kind of thing. It's messy. Intent...

Yes. That said, I'm glad that rangers have moved from the wilder-nazi style of favored enemy that encouraged that kind of design. I...

So the players were mad his character was ineffective? I guess its true that its Rude to Suck at WoW, but that highlights a certain...

It has never been able to do this. People try to do it. Wizards (and TSR) market it like it can. But it can't.

'There are no turtlemen in my setting whatsoever, and that's that' is quite a strong position to take IMO. It rules out an entire...

That fine. I'm pretty sure your game would be too narrow and hemmed in for me anyway. I'd be a museum tourist allowed to...

Its actually ironic, I don't have a tortle PC idea. I was using it because it was the original example. That said, I am DYING to play...

I always question this line of thinking. I used to run my own homebrew for a while and I can tell you with 100% certainty I did NOT...

The Tortle came from another dimension/world. Hopefully this is an answer both sides will dislike while still fulfilling both...

I think that's where the "compromise" framing falls apart. I am look for a compromise of "How can I play the character I want in a way...

You're mistaken, I don't see it as compromise because there's nothing to compromise for. "I don't like you having a top hat, how about...

The question asked was "what is my motivation besides I want to". It doesn't matter why I want to. My motivation is neither sinister nor...

Do I need to justify why I want to be a wizard instead of a fighter?. Do I need to justify why my character is an elf to play one...

Why can't Kreko Kegshatter be a human? Why can't your orc be a halfling who was raised by elves? Why can't all of those characters be...