Recent content by Remus Lupin

The worst book in any edition is clearly The Stronghold Builder's Guidebook from Third Edition. I was so looking forward to that. What a piece of garbage.

I thought this was really good news at first, but then I remembered that legit actor Jeremy Irons was in the OG D&D movie.

Wouldn't launch on either of my Macs. I'm going to try to install it in Windows and see if it runs. If not, also asking for my money back.

Yes, I believe it was noted at the time. I think that's what set many people off.

I like this way of expressing it, and it does a better job of expressing what I'm trying to say than I have. I've never denied it's a question of preferences, with some preferring 5e and others PF2. What seems strange to me is that this conversation seemed to begin with the idea that PF2 is...

It seems some folks are arguing that it both has less stuff AND even more stuff!

Imaro, ignored.

Exactly.

I'm sorry the fact that I am not fond of the way 5e handles this, and the fact that it provides what I consider to be limited and unexciting options causes you so much personal angst. But the fact remains that this is how I feel about it. I'm always at a loss as to how people think they can...

That's right, and I still disagree.

Sure. That's there. It really doesn't do much for me. Again, I'm thinking here primarily of what's available in terms of class options. I'll agree with respect to backgrounds there's a lot to work with there, but I'm just not fond of the implementation.

I disagree.

Having played the game bi-weekly for several years now, and having created dozens of characters, and having watched the other players in my game create dozens of characters, and having seen, repeatedly, the same three flavors of every class, with only the occasional exception, I stand by my...

And just for the record: I still disagree. The way that options are parsed in 5e feels paltry to me even when you take account of supplementary sources. Meanwhile, I think that Paizo's options are robust right out of the box, without me having to go out and invest in supplementary sources just...

I didn't ignore them for disagreeing with me. I ignored them for being a jerk about it.