ReptartheGrand's latest activity

Oh I like your 18+ to hit idea that does simplify things. Thanks for your input. I guess I used the Dex as a gate keeper because in our...

I'm not a fan of items/abilities/anything else that only work for characters that are already super strong. 1e had a lot of stuff like...

It is probably both underpowered and to my thinking too fiddly to use. In that the 25+ to activate will be forgotten too many times in...

Oh and as for your any weapon or rapier question, in the dndBeyond homebrew section I used the +1 Magic weapon as template and the added...

I didn’t even know that existed (still relatively new to dnd). I talked it over with my DM and she said to take off the 25 dmg...

The weapon says any, but then goes to Rapier, is it supposed to be Rapier only? Second attack only happens IF 25+ damage? So basically...

If I'm reading this right, it's wildly underpowered. You need to do 25 damage in a single hit to get a +1 weapon for one attack? Even...

Oh no I think you misunderstood, it’s a +1 Magic weapon so it gets +1 on attack and damage rolls as a base. Getting 25 is to activate...

Thank you for the welcome and advice. And haha yeah it’s basically for rouges.

@ReptartheGrand first, welcome to the boards. Second, generally anything people ask if it is too powerful- it is. I never heard of a...

I wanted to create a weapon that allows one extra attack for classes that can’t get one. My DM is cool with it but another player says...