Reynard's latest activity

I think almost stealing the tuning forks probably caused more afront than if you had simply stopped planar travel magic working because...

Also, and this might better be a subject for a second thread, I don't think "prep fiat" is any more valid than "play fiat."

While I don't wholeheartedly disagree, I think this sort of appeals to the authority of the books and/or rules in a way that is...

Interesting, I had not thought about GM fiat as a form of railroading.

I think its closer to the Action RPG than Souls like (IMO). Some combat is difficult, but its not so brutal that you have to memorize...

As I have said since the OP, I definitely railroaded the party INTO the scenario. But i also don't think it remains a railroad after...

Not unless it has to be completed no matter what the players decide. If they can opt to walk in, and then opt to leave or head back to...

There were no blocked exit points. All that happened was that the tuning forks were stolen. There was no sequence of events. There was...

I was replying to @TheSword who suggested stopping the player from using plane shift to just immediately leave the faewild was stopping...

That seems like a cynical ploy to get people to post Simpson memes, my friend.

Sure, but I was referring to casting plane shift in order to, you know, shift planes.

Aside: is casting a standard spell for its intended purpose a "creative solution"?

How small can a railroad be? Is a linear dungeon design a railroad?

I don't think "a situation" can be "a railroad" since the latter requires some sort of movement on the rails. I don't think "You are...

Just because certain story paths have a clear line to a solution/ending...doesnt make it a railroad. If there was only one magical key...