robertsconley's latest activity

Well said.

Into the Majestic Fantasy Realms: The Northern Marches pre-launch. I'm excited to announce that my third Kickstarter launches on...

If what I quoted doesn't explain all the nuances, then by all means, explain and show us the original text so we can verify its...

I believe the readers of the thread now have the information to arrive at their own conclusions on the accuracy of @AlViking statement...

I want to be clear about what I have been saying, because at this point you keep insisting I am wrong while describing exactly what I am...

Thank You now I can answer your questions. In Burning Wheel, whether an Intent+Task is an example of character agency or meta-agency...

I believe it from Burning Wheel but somebody familiar with the system should explain it so we understand all the naunces.

The “we skedaddle” example is a player describing what their characters are doing in the moment, in response to the immediate situation...

Your examples only show the declaration, which is character agency. To give a full answer I need the rules for the how the action is...

You say you’re only talking about character agency, but the systems you reference, Burning Wheel, Torchbearer, and 4e D&D, rely on...

No, that’s not doing something as your character. Declaring goals to the referee is a player-level action. Your character doesn’t know...

Character Agency

Pemerton, you’ve repeatedly accused me of mischaracterizing your views. I disagree. What I’ve done is analyze your arguments using a...

It depends on the specifics of how actions are declared. To answer I will need the specific rules in question.

yes. It is not a consequence of acting as their character. But something they are doing as a player in the campaign.