SableWyvern's latest activity

You have made it clear that it doesn't work for you; I don't think it's unreasonable for people to suggest that you accept this. It...

I appreciated @robertsconley walking through way he evaluated the decision space around the noblewomen reacting to possibilities...

PbtA games' GM Principles seem to me to be a explicit codification of what has generally been considered GM best practices. They're like...

Only people can pretend to be people and have it be any good.

That is your objective. It is not ours. I don't want a setting that functions like a machine. I want a human managing the setting...

It's certainly my objective, and every person you're arguing with has said the same thing on multiple occasions Too bad you're having...

I've gone to significant effort to explain this for you on a couple of occasions, but you ignore those responses so you can rant at...

Then how is it that so many people appear to play this way? Your IMO hyperbolic concerns seem to assume a massive player underclass...

Depends how true one is to one's self-imposed constraints, I suppose.

I'll cop to a failing of my own: I never put enough lakes and ponds and swamps in to any map I do, probably because I find doing so to...

Well, of course the game designed with the specific intent of constraining the GM does so more than a system that empowers the GM to...

The underlying disagreement here seems mostly to be not actually about the decision making process, so much as the player relationship...

I’ve said before that my players can, and do, challenge outcomes, ask questions, and analyze what happened based on what they know or...

Really this whole argument boils down to 1. Most of the thread has been people arguing against 1, but I don't think any of us have been...

I'm not, 1) since your premise of 100% matching the real world is not one anyone uses or necessary, 2) you can in fact(and it is a fact)...