SkidAce's latest activity

Here is an example to chew on: A BBEG casts command on a PC and the PC fails the save. the command is Flee. The PC is in a big open...

In the hallway example where all things are equal I'd put it to a die roll or coin flip as to which way the target goes.

I would let the player choose for the character in that situation. IMHO, its good to have the player involved. Even if in a different...

Aaaand the thread has turned into another Player vs GM Agency debate.

While I have no problem with character stats or traits being involved in how things play out, I’d much prefer it be in a direct way…...

Late to the thread but my definition is pretty straightforward: railroading is when a player's action declaration would ruin the plot...

And some of it is simply a question of aptitude. I've noted before you can have GMs who are naturally good at some aspects of the role...

Not sure what is meant by "a means to deal with the consequences of the draw" either.

I legit do not understand how the inclusion of the Deck is rairoading. No one has to draw.

For sure. I think at least some portion of GM railroading comes from insecurity: that is, being uncertain about being able to flow with...

Yes, it absolutely should. #BlueSupremacy

No worries! I understand better now.

Sorry, I didn't mean to come across as if I was arguing with you. Yes - I get what you're saying. I was just adding: It's not like...

This, of course, leads to the problem of perceived railroading. Sometimes players do not have perfect knowledge of a situation, so "no"...

When I get a chance I will look through my Dungeon Adventures spreadsheet, but for now let me second these that others have mentioned...