I understand your points, but the person I quoted was talking about homogeneity, so I was wondering about their viewpoint.
You thoughts also make sense and help me see the span of influences from a different viewpoint.
An honest question to gain perspective....
How much does "homogeneity" matter for you? It seems to matter on the internet, cause many of us read the class guides with letter ranks and color codes, and over time as you say they "home in" on certain builds.
While they were doing that our group...
You are correct in that people can get obsessed with chains and choices. Here's why we normally dont run into that problem (and it colors our way of thinking about stuff that would be bloat to other folks
People gain Prestige Classes/Feat Chains organically, or conceptually.
"Hey that BBG...
Totally agree, especially for organizational "prestige" classes. Buy into the org as much as you would like. Some orgs wont let you "buy" the feat unless you have enough renown.
We also use feat chains to simulate learning special magic styles. Works better than subclasses...you can only...
I'm not a rocket scientist, but could they both have been at the other ends of their orbits from earth...putting them in the same direction relatively?