soviet's latest activity

Then, as 5e fans have long said to 4e fans, I guess The Market Has Spoken

But what all these forum and restaurant analogies miss, is that with RPGs your old books don't vanish and you can just keep playing...

But suspending the D&D part of the forums would stop you talking about D&D. Publishing a new edition doesn't do anything to stop you...

I've never once gone out looking for players of a specific RPG. I've only ever played in an existing group, and chosen a game.

Yeah, it becomes pretty clear over time that treating knowledge skills like task skills doesn't really produce things that meet the...

But does that mean you need a skill system, with a list of discrete skills? I am perfectly content with using background/class: "I was...

Well, except that all your old books still exist.

Maybe, maybe not. Admittedly, I was not there. But, while exposure is required, it may not be sufficient. You didn't mention any...

It took you 1.5 years of play to realise that 4e wasn't built around sim priorities? This is like trying sushi in the hope it will...

Don't McDonalds rotate things in and out of their menu all the time? Is that exclusionary of people who like those items?

Yeah, I was also quite upset when the WotC’s agents broke into my house and burned all my 3e books. Talk about aggressive marketing!

Haven't you chosen to play with those different rules by engaging with the new edition? It's not like it's an online game where the...

that a game system doesn't appeal to your or someone else's tastes still doesn't mean that it was at all designed to exclude you or...

Nothing you like has changed even slightly. Your books still exist. What's happened is that something new has come out. You're not...

Unless you were born with those preferences, yes.