Sulicius's latest activity

Yeah that's what I meant? I only meant that maybe in some previous edition they did.

While I agree with a lot of his take, and am having some of the same issues with 2024 - particularly the “mechanics first...

HD never matched CR. A single HD is not enough a bump of HP to make the offense of 4 bad underpowered PCs. You need 15-20 HP per CR...

That’s not how humans work. The more we like something the more likely we are to not like a change to that thing no matter how small...

You'd think that! It's pretty clear they don't build monsters this way. Looking at most other NPC statblocks will tell you this. CR6...

Wait, so you introduced a house-rule that directly goes against 5e14 and 2e24 rules and design and you're using that baseline to argue...

Wait you guys have been playing the game? I thought the game only existed to make up hypotheticals to own other nerds with

Even if you count for appointments there are replacements walking around who are valid enough to be members. Even with 3 being jokes...

Each member? Not the impression I had. Maybe more like half of them?

Really? The 2024 monsters have seen significant improvements in power from tier 2 onwards. My experience is that it has never been...

Your opinions on 5e 2024 aren’t right or wrong, they’re your opinions. However, your post suggesting that people are calling Keith a...

I feel like the argument about the Warrior Commander’s stats is coming from the fact that people see a generic, non-spellcasting...

Well, it certainly points to the unintended consequences of the system design. Keith's objections to this model really require a lower...

Good job passing the "tell me you haven't read the thread without telling me you haven't read the thread" challenge.

No one here should be taking Keith's decision personally. You and he are allowed to go different ways.