Thagdal's latest activity

You're conflating two separate things there.

I think its great! So clearly Sandy has been doing his research (and GMing of 12+ years working towards this system.) - Its very...

I'm not sure how the thread got on this tangent, but about AL, I will say, during my stint as a DM for AL, despite the fact that it's...

I have a profound dislike for this decision, the people making it, and the reasons they give. That's the most polite response I can...

Only for the KS, I think. In future it won’t. Still they need to have cards available outside the core in some way. I don’t...

Talking about our gaming experiences gives us the opportunity to sanity check, compare impressions with and get feedback from other...

I played the red box, 1e, 2e and at no time did I have constant TPK's. I had the rare character death but it wasn't happening all the...

And not being gatekeepy. Picking creators to highlight (and, by definition, creators not to highlight) is never a good idea if you are...

And that's a problem because? As a very small publisher I can tell you that the creative part I can do, but the costs of printing and...

but this very much sounded like it which is what I replied to

There are whole classes dedicated to combat. A large part of the rules are about fighting or what happens when you fight. This combat...

Yeah... no, this is wrong and not how 5e is played... at most it's possibly how some choose to play 5e.

This may a retroactive tenet of OSR play but it does not mirror my experiences in playing those older games at the time, and I think the...

I think that there's a disconnection between GMing styles and what Shadowdark could do well. First off, Basic D&D adventures from the...

Honestly, if that were my experience, I absolutely could (and would) judge the system based on that. This wasn't simply a one and done -...