The reason that I quoted your post wasn't to prove you wrong. Itis just that the example you have chosen to demonstrate your point wasn't valid since it is not an equal measurement.
For the record I had DMed SCAP and played in both STAP and AOW. My experience with SCAP was that there were...
Exactly the same as you put it in Paizo messageboards.
I didn't have time to answer you there but now that I can I want to point out that Paizo sells one adventure along with info from Golarion. Dungeon must have several adventures. In addition, you have not seen what other chapters of Dungeon...
For this I'm on the other side of the fence. My players to find out whether they are minions should either hear the discription, make a knowledge check or check by trial and error. Even with Knowledge check, I definitely won't tell them the name but I will describe them as clearly a weak target...
I don't think we have to wait much since today is the day for the ritual excerpt by wizards (as far as I remember). I think that it will address many of the issues mentioned.
Hope I remember well.