That's still just the same thing, and I wasn't implying that it would be an ancient dragon at level 1 either. So even with your clarification, my statement still stands.
One reason is that the actual numbers or amount of dice something has is just an abstraction. So all the a PC dragons need is...
Not being exactly like the NPC stat blocks doesn't mean it's not following the rules, it's just admitting that the rules for PCs and Monsters/NPCs are different. It doesn't need to be an exact match for the dragon MM stats anymore than the other PC classes need to be a match for the NPC stat blocks.
I actually don't have a problem with building regular PCs and monster PCs differently, as the goal isn't to build things the same way, but to have a comparable level of power after they're built. And even in 3E the only thing that was the same between PCs and monsters was that HD and the number...
Here is a good series about what railroading is
So yeah, I don't agree that PotA is a railroad due to the difficulty levels of the areas, still it can be a bit annoying and preventative towards the exploring absolutely everywhere. I'd have liked to see the places on each layer being a bit...
Oooh! *GRABS*
I shall have to try this out sometime for certain... just need more time >.>
It'd be interesting to have a mixed party and one of the "humanoid" members had my Polymorphed Dragon background.
I'd allow it. I'm even going to make a subrace of dragonborn that's basically it that has a slightly slower flying speed but higher natural attack damage, in place of the BW and resistance.
Obviously there's a local young dragoness who takes a liking to one of the party members, but her parents want him to provide a decent dowry first (not too small, not too big). Benefits of this are a friendly dragon and perhaps a small bit of influence on the dragon council. :)
I'm working on a new setting for my first 5E campaign, sometime in the distant (but hopefully not too far) future.
The world has had a cataclysmic invasion by elves and lesser fey (gnomes, goblins, etc.) and the only safe places from them for humanity to live in are within the territory of...