The-Magic-Sword's latest activity

Perhaps that shows your problem with interpreting the three is one of empathy where player to gm ratio at just about every table leaves...

It doesn't matter what they think. It's a functional compromise whether they want to agree to it or not. Here's the situation. DM: The...

Um, no. You don't get to tell me that I can't have fun in world creation that has some limitations built in. Or that it's wrong for me...

This might be acceptable to me, especially as a reflavor of the tortle statblock, and if you let me be cute about it.

Hmm, the character wouldn't look the way I wanted them to, and they wouldn't be cold blooded which means their people wouldn't have the...

Before we switched to Pathfinder I had a tortle light cleric i wanted to play, i had this idea about tortles meditating in open sky...

This. I have seen people argue that a player should not have to walk and that there are so few DMs that the DM is obligated to...

I think what I'm wondering is, how strong do we understand a guard captain to be in the story? What kind of villain is he? How hard is...

Are we discussing whether story or mechanics are coming first? Or are we talking about our mutual understanding of what the story is in...

Looking back at this thread, I think that one major thing is that this is, in some ways, an outgrowth over how the concept of an...

I think complaining about creature ststblocks with things like an 18 attrib and mundane weapon rather than a 12 & choice between useless...

I think there's a kind of inertia working against specific licensed games like this unless the property is stratospherically popular...