Tigris's latest activity

Well the decision that everyone should be useful in a fight was a good decision. Just that they forgot to also make everyone useful...

education in medieval is pretty much equal to really stupid in D&D fantasy world, being able to read and doing some basic math. Also...

For a real life example of a fighting man that had many other skills, consider the Roman Legionnaire. Pretty much defines the basic D&D...

Well but it does not seam anything thats the thing. Thats just again GMs thinking they can decide what players should feel. No sorry...

Actually, I think the bigger problem with 5e (and 2024 exacerbates it) is that there's only TWO classes in the game for people who don't...

I dont say 4E had no non combat things, I say the fighter got screwed out of combat in 4E: He has literally 0 utility abilities which...

Any knight in any medieval movie or book etc.

Agree to disagree. The game needed a way to resolve characters being good at things other than combat, and basing it entirely on...

Thats something we cannot know. Only the players know. Because players assume a GM is consequent and when magic does not work all magic...

I think the problem is more that "fighter" is a general name, but the class is more specific. From the people you named for me only...

Investigating how the fork was stolen / trying to find the fork does lead into the railroad though, to investigate this situation...

Go back and re-read TwoSix post. And mine for that matter. As well you are making a non-valid dichotomy between situation and plot...

Its so not useful when GMs answer in such threads. Its like dictators discussing amongthemselves why their subjects should be glad about...

If you want to set up straw men for your rhetoric there's no reason to continue this conversation.

This is not choice this is "guess what the DM wants to hear." The choice is "we want to get out of here". And using the specific tool...