TiQuinn's latest activity

Okay fine, not a terrible thing. Is a “bad” thing more appropriate? Not fun? A downer?

What the heck is the “long run”? We’re here to have the players generate conflict and narratives. That’s the point of playing.

I’m sure this was a while ago, so I’m not criticizing any GM actions here. But it seems like a solid example of a time to make sure...

Because you keep using it pejoratively. It’s the posture of the posts that make me feel this didn’t work out the way you wanted, but you...

Of course, but I also don’t look back years later (I’m assuming this was years ago since it was a 3e game) as if it were a terrible...

But again - Why blame the player? Was the player unhappy? If they wanted to play a character who was pushing the envelope, why is that a...

I continue to see multiple contradictions. You say it was not an unfun game session but you’re sad after the fact. You express...

That seems very strange to me and again a bit incongruous with the description of the player’s choice. To be more precise, why sit in...

That’s fine but I would also say that we were playing a more deadly high stakes game, the player knew those risks and wanted to roll...

No, he described what the player chose and the outcome. He didn’t describe how he portrayed the choice to the player, and I think...

I keep coming back to your own phrasing in your posts. I’m sorry if that sounds like a DM horror story but you’re making it sound like a...

The way you’re describing both the player and the character even in this post indicates to me that you still don’t like the way the...

Man, I read this post and I’m not sure how it sounds to you in your head as you’re typing it out but I’m hearing someone who either...

Let me ask this: when this happened in your campaign, was this acceptable to those players after you told them that you thought their...

Putting forward a compromise that none of your players considers a compromise tells me it’s a bad compromise.