I have to admit that being able to gather enough food to feed 2+ people for a day in a few minutes without magic stretches my disbelief much more than being more awesome at hunting, but I'm loving all of this LU stuff a ton and thanks for the responses!
Or am I missing something? With Expert Foraging, you get 2-6 supply per day that also restores 2-6 hp, and with Huntsman, you get 0-2 supply per day, with an (extremely unlikely) possibility of a level of fatigue for everyone.
It's almost like, after nerfing Goodberry for cooler travel stories...