Willie the Duck's latest activity

I wouldn't say the document is a joke. Including examples in a how-to guide is not exactly against the spirit or purpose of the thing. I...

Mod note: The trenches here seem to be dug and probably aren't going to reveal any striking new thoughts on the matter. As events...

At the same time, 2e included all but the most broken stat generation methods 1E and 1.5 had in the book as methods. I know 2e called...

I don't recall that anybody claimed Bledsaw would be actively engaged in writing for the new version of CSIO. Or doing edits or layout...

Well then I think the rest of my post is pertinent: both 1e and 2e have massive issues, and people aren't really playing by-the-book 1e...

Like all things of that era, any comment about 'how we all played' is innately mistaken. However, 'how we all played' in my social...

I think you are both right at times. IMO, psionics in AD&D (particularly playing a Psionicist class in 2e) did feel different, but the...

I mean fine, if you want to be conventional and all. The difference is that this is real. Not even sold as a novelty (well, maybe as a...

It's gotta be either that or just an allusion to how the author (Jason Carl, who wrote 3.0's Sword & Fist where it first appeared)...

Why stop there?

Let's see. For two weapon fighting: in theory you can now dual-wield flails, rapiers, whips, etc., for d8 damage or whip reach. In...

Because they are all working on 17 different projects at once, their playtesting is outsourced and when the documents come in there's...

I don't hate psionics as spellcasters. When we talk about spells (particularly 'spells' in the way that Book of Nine Swords maneuvers...

Ugh. That's what I meant to type. Wow is that easy to do.