W'rkncacnter's latest activity

past tense presumably used for when choosing to be a half elf actually mattered mechanically in the game.

Drop a fireball on me, we're cool; most of my friends try to kill me sooner or later anyway. Cast an enchantment spell on me, and after...

i would assume the answer to that is "if you're using this ability on them, you're not friends"

What I'm getting from this debate is apparently casting any sort of spell (helpful or harmful) could be viewed as PVP, regardless if...

What a weird white room argument. At our table, the player with Commander’s Strike would ask their other party member if they’d like to...

Because martial control abilities only apply to enemies? Or do you consider buffing spells like Haste or Bless PvP?

The reason they don't is because there aren't any (or at least no-one has presented an example) Every martial one we've been considering...

I mean, sure. As far as I follow the argument-- I'm only seeing one side of it-- the main problem with the power is whether or not the...

Ok, so given that the 4e version is a Melee power with a range of your melee weapon reach, requiring you to be in the thick of it to use...

...okay...but...i don't really see the problem in, say, reflavouring commander's strike from a command to pointing out a gap in an...

But now another player has influenced my decision, which is a horrible violation of player agency! /s

you don't even have to rewrite anything. you can just ignore the flavour text and describe it differently. ...you...dislike...

Paladin: Your forces are beaten, Eye of Gruumsh. Surrender and I will spare you miserable life. Eye of Gruumsh: I surrender. ::Falls to...

reminds me of some of those DnD horror stories about how 'the atheist party member refused to be healed by my cleric'

you can literally just reflavour that. it is not that hard.