zakael19's latest activity

When I think of "generative resolution" a la Harper's blog, I'm thinking of making a Hard Move on a Miss that adds something to teh...

I would also like to state that I support any and all adjudication that involves ninjas.

It is usually just either less effective or more dangerous, not both. It cannot be more difficult, as the "difficulty" is just based on...

No, position / effect is how we communicate your fictional position (how much risk is there in doing this), and what will you get from...

Yeah, @hawkeyefan and myself both noted that. Generally if you want to do something that's just like, harder to pull off based on...

FWIW, part of the Threat Roll redux in Harper's Deep Cuts is designed to alleviate some of these issues he'd seen around the internet in...

I think that’s a fair comment. Speaking for myself, when I was playing Scum and Villany, I was expecting a more free flowing narrative...

No, I’m not blind. What a douchey way to disagree. I have run both types of campaigns as well. I’m not blind to the differences. I...

My take away from this is that, for the skill list to work, (i) the table has to care about the difference between getting in close and...

This made a lot of sense to me! I can't really credit that the way players debate and discuss among one another and work out their...

By "internal consistency", you seem to mean something like "has a uniformity of trope and tone". Not a property of the fiction from the...

My question here is why do you consider consistency the biggest virtue rather than at the very least the Scylla to the Charybdis of...

** Sigh ** The game is free. Go play it. It's meant to be played solo as a default mode of play. Go try it out for 2-3 hours. It's a...

Yes, there’s a difference between a player actively seeking to position things to his character’s strengths than “just describing it...

Yes. I'm saying there's a bunch of Player Principles about not going "I MUST USE MY BEST ABILITY OR FAIL." They're in the book. I dont...