Recent content by Zephyr9

Let's take the case of Hold Person vs Mirror Image: - MI interpretation #1 - Hold Person is not an Attack (does not require an attack roll): Hold Person caster chooses his Target (the MI caster). He CANNOT target an image because HP only targets creatures an an image is not a creature. Since HP...

I think that in the case of something like Hold Person vs Mirror Image there are 2 issues: 1- is Hold Person an attack spell? 2- Does the caster of Hold Person have to choose which 'image' to target? I think the PH clearly indicates that Hold Person is not an attack spell: As for targeting, I...

I can see that there is a lot of debate about whether Magic Missile is an attack and how it interacts with Mirror Image. But what about all the spells that don't require to-hit rolls such as Hold Person, Frostbite, Charm Person, Banishment, etc... Are these attacks? Do they always affect the...